Descending minor and major third

[originalvonster]

I'm really struggling with identifying these when they are descending, any tips? I particularly struggle when they are in a different octave to the interval example songs I am using (Hey Jude and Swing Low).

[Quentin]

Descending 3rds can be tricky as Major 3rd descending sounds like the beginning of a minor triad played descending (and vice-versa with a minor 3rd). So when in doubt, you could try to sing the rest of the triad.

[fnfunkin]

I’ve definitely struggled with descending intervals too, especially when they’re in a lower or higher octave than the examples I know. It helps me to hum the interval downward slowly first and compare it to a familiar melody, even if it’s not the same octave. Over time, my ear started recognizing the shape of the interval rather than just the absolute pitch.

[coralester]

Yeah, I can relate to that a lot. Focusing on the “shape” of the interval instead of the exact pitch really makes a difference. Humming it slowly is a great approach too—I’ve found that practicing in different octaves helps train the ear to stay consistent no matter where the notes sit.